This is a question that was asked on the "other" site. Given the complexities of this case, I think it's a reasonable question. My take is that the U.S. Government has the Trust Responsibility, and I'm satisfied that the pleadings so far have shown that they breached that trust. The Communities, Shakopee in particular, were "enriched" by this breach. As a result, they may be summoned in to the case..remember, USGov was the first to raise that possibility, as I understand it, to help pay the bill if not to "foot it" entirely. The Communities, LS excepted, are responsible for causing this legal mess, because if they had practiced fair and reasonable enrollment policies, this case would very likely never have been filed in the first place. The first litigants would have been accorded their rights as enrolled tribal members, and the rest of us would never have had reason to get involved..although Gov would still have been guilty of breaching their Trust Responsibility to the linear descendents. Tokakte
You are correct, dakota20. And I look for them to fight being summoned with everything they can muster. They know that the only reason they're being invited to the party is to pick up the check. The Indian Tucker Act provides for this possibility, and apparently they can't use tribal sovereignty to avoid being summoned. tokakte
I understand what you are saying Jamie. It is frustrating to participate in a don't have time to communicate with the likes of you lawsuit. I suppose for me is the positiveness that when this is over, we as people will have a choice and Dr. B will no longer have that illusional power of people. Hang in there, we are all getting close.
Jamie, you make a good point. However, I have a hunch that this case will take a long time in any event. This motion by Erik and Co. sort of took me by surprise. I figured USGov would move to summon when they had lost and were facing a huge settlement bill. This move by Erik may have caught Gov off guard also, because they look like they have been saving their legal ammunition for the appeal. Now, PI and Shakopee will have to get involved in a big way to protect their per capita income; but I can't really see how many new legal issues are left to be raised. In sum, I think Erik and Co. pulled a clever move, forcing Gov and the three tribes to play in Judge Lettow's Court and not a the next level. I admit, this is all speculation, and I could be dead wrong. But things are definitely going to get even more lively from now on. Tokakte
I have read the "Beyond Sovereignty: The Mdewakanton Identity Heist." Written By Dr. Barbara Feezor Buttes. In this book it mentions that the Lower Sioux Community Council had the Jurisdiction to make recommendations to the Bureau for 1886 Land Leases at Prior Lake. Does this Jurisdiction help us Mdewakanton in any way at giving us leverage to acheive the status of sharing all benefits equally amongst all three communities? & If so it'll be mostly decided upon through votes by all three communities. Right?
I have read the "Beyond Sovereignty: The Mdewakanton Identity Heist." Written By Dr. Barbara Feezor Buttes. In this book it mentions that the Lower Sioux Community Council had the Jurisdiction to make recommendations to the Bureau for 1886 Land Leases at Prior Lake. Does this Jurisdiction help us Mdewakanton in any way at giving us leverage to achieve the status of sharing all benefits equally among st all three communities? & If so it'll be mostly decided upon through votes by all three communities. Right?
3 communities...well what about the rest that do not live in those communities, and yet they share equally in the claim? Your question is highly educated?
But here I would say NO! well, why you ask? because your question came in a sentence that states they had the the jurisdiction, but now they do not? It is hard to determine this from a had, and do they still posess the ability to make the recommendation?
I would say no, but maybe someone else has the answer?
DO NOT COPY MY IMAGES WITH OUT MY PERMISSION!! IT IS COPYRIGHTED.
I am clueless to the current situation with the Jurisdiction issue. Perhaps it would be best if Prior Lake simply loses it's Federal Recognition all together due to it's impostor status? & That would most likely lead to a unity between Lower Sioux & Prairie Island? Even though I"ve heard Prairie Island is similar to Prior Lake, & is currently occupied by non lineal descendants as well. So....what would happen to the Prior Lake 1886 Lands if Prior Lake loses it's Federal Recognition status, due to it's fraudulent & unlawful establishment?
If Lower Sioux currently had Jurisdiction at Prior Lake. Voted Crooks out, & establish a new council & community consisting of true direct lineal descendants. Things would be better dayz. Maybe, Lower Sioux should ask for Jurisdiction over Prior Lake through congress. After all, Lower Sioux does consist of enough members to be a community with such power. & why would Congress deny Prior Lake's 75% + impostor status? Congress would much rather destroy a fraudulent claim. Right?
As I understand it, all this certification business is needed to make this case a "class action suit", like the Cobell Case. I'm sure there are those in LS that think that they have a preferential position in deciding how and what damages can be awarded, but I think that all of us are on equal footing; and that the settlement will be equally divided among us if we win. I don't see how the court can set up different levels of worthiness that would see some of the damages go members of the three communities, and some lesser amount to the rest of us are enrolled elsewhere.
By the way, Dakota20, you're right again. Congress giveth and Congress taketh away. Maybe Shakopee should never have been recognized, and even though some argue that they are a "community" and not a "tribe", they are a federally recognized tribe as far as the law is concerned, and the judge can't touch that.
mdenney: If you post anything but research info you will get banned
Jan 10, 2020 17:30:51 GMT -5
krys: Does any one know of an official site where I can get info on Jacob Eastmen many lightnings from when he was a boy his father, mother etc and who they were. Thank you
May 21, 2020 6:30:10 GMT -5
mindleaphealth50: Mindleap App - Mindleap is a telehealth platform that connects people with integration coaches and other mental health specialists.
Jun 28, 2020 5:42:35 GMT -5
chadmaloy: Hello, I am new here and wondering of anyone can help with verifying if the information I found is accurate....
Jul 4, 2020 16:04:48 GMT -5
chadmaloy: Wabasha II Necohundah Lefeuille One Eye married to Sister of Ho-Chunk Chief Winneshiek
Daughter-Hazawastewin married to Etarz-e-pah L’Arc
Daughter Zoe Cankuomainwin Roche (1810-1846) married to Lewis Martin (1803-1858)
Daughter Mary Marie Mar
Jul 4, 2020 16:04:52 GMT -5
himes001: I am researching William Baine. He married Maggie Holy Face and possibly someone named Susan. I big on having documentation and haveyfound any for Susan. Any suggestions.
Aug 10, 2020 18:42:53 GMT -5
wyomingcowboy: Hello nightwolf. Did you find answers to your questions? I, also, am a great great grandson of Thomas Flood. My grandmother is Cornelia Louise Stead Penn and is also buried in Rosebud. I would like to connect with you if you're still around.
Aug 20, 2020 14:38:21 GMT -5
himes001: I also need help verifying information that I have found for the William Baine family?
Sept 22, 2020 21:58:20 GMT -5
Sominex: Sorry for the late reply! Are you still there OrangeDeluxe? I don't have much on her (Tateaicagewin), but I do have a few documents I can share with you. Email me at Lori_WalkingEagle@hotmail.com
Nov 18, 2020 19:42:32 GMT -5
joyshoe: I am researching Catherine Sell Delaney. There is a book with information about her son Cyrus. The book is "The Saga of Sully Flats". Can anyone with the book do a look-up for me? TIA
Mar 17, 2021 13:08:25 GMT -5
oldbetzdna: I have a small paragraph from the Iapi Oye I would like translated from Dakota to English. Is there anyone available to do this? I am happy to pay them for their services.
Jul 25, 2021 17:33:07 GMT -5
stormie23: Hi, my name is Lisa E Groce Aguayo. I am a new member on here and I.m looking for information on my dad's side of the family. They were very secretive. I am looking for information on all the Charles C. Mitchells if you please.
Jul 31, 2021 22:15:45 GMT -5